Proposed Amendment TECH-2005-01
Discontinue use of the “Classic HERS® Score”
Proponent: RESNET Standing Technical Committee
Proposed Changes: This change requires the deletion of
definitions referring to the Classic and Expanded HERS scores (Section
302), deletion of all references to Classic and Expanded HERS Scores
in the body of the Standards (various
Sections) and deletion of the equations used to calculate the
Classic HERS score (Section 303.2).
Justification: Originally RESNET considered making the
expanded score the only rating method. However, due to concerns raised
by EPA, it was made optional and it appeared that the only score that
would be accepted for ENERGY STAR was the "HERS Classic" (using only
heating, cooling, and water heating end uses). Because EPA has committed
to use the Expanded score as its ENERGY STAR performance path, we
propose that the Classic HERS score should not be used; rather, that the
expanded score replace the existing HERS score. Not only would the use
of two scores create confusion in the marketplace, but the "Classic"
score would not represent the "old" score at all--only the new reference
home applied to the old end-use calculation of heating, cooling and
water heating--so instead of a "new" and "old" score this would actually
introduce a third, different score into people's thinking. This proposed
change has already been moved and accepted by the RESNET board.
Comment period is over. View comments
received. |